Blog / Free Advice and Other Musings

Publicity updates are rich in detail —but it’s difficult to map that activity to your sales data

If you work at a small or mid-sized publishing house, this probably sounds familiar:

Every few weeks, you receive a detailed publicity update (often as a nicely formatted email), which includes reviews, interviews, best-of lists, excerpts, events by title. It’s clearly good news — but when someone asks:

• Can we see the impact of publicity in our GA4, Shopify, or sales data?
• Is this working?
• Which books should we support with marketing

…the answers are fuzzy.

This post isn’t about turning publicity into performance marketing. It’s about giving sales and marketing a lightweight, realistic way to make publicity usable in analytics and decision-making — without overpromising ROI.

First: what publicity is (and isn’t)

Publicity doesn’t behave like paid media. It rarely comes with clean links back to your site, timestamps, or even attribution.

What it does do well:

1. Awareness & discovery
   • New audiences
   • New geographies
2. Credibility & validation
   • Trade confidence
   • Awards, lists, reviews
3. Momentum & longevity
   • Best-of lists
   • Bestseller persistence
4. Activation support
   • Gives marketing something to amplify
   • Improves email, social, retail confidence

Think of publicity as a multiplier, not a conversion channel.

Analytics can’t prove that a single media hit sold books — but it can help you see where earned attention is turning into real audience interest.

Step 1: Decide which publicity is worth measuring

Not all coverage deserves analytics attention.

Create simple outlet tiers tailored to your coverage:

• Tier 1: Mass reach / authority (national broadcasters, major influencers)
• Tier 2: Industry and literary influence (trade and respected book outlets)
• Tier 3: Community and niche (blogs, podcasts, substacks)

For reporting purposes, focus on Tier 1 and Tier 2. This keeps effort proportional to signal.

Step 2: Turn an unstructured email into usable data

You don’t need automation or perfection. You need consistency.

For each publicity email, do one quick extraction pass into a shared spreadsheet. Capture:

• Title
• Author
• Outlet
• Coverage type (review, list, excerpt, interview)
• Date (Month-Year is fine)
• Market (Canada / US / UK / International)

One row per hit. Dropdowns where possible. Skip anything that’s vague or internal-only.

Estimate: 15–30 minutes per reporting period.

Step 3: Apply a lightweight publicity score

Instead of asking “Did this sell books?”, ask:

Which titles have the strongest earned-media momentum right now?

A simple score helps answer that consistently.

Outlet weight (example)

• Tier 1 (mass reach): 5 points
• Tier 2 (industry influencer) : 3 points
• Tier 3 (niche influencer) : 1 points

Coverage type

• Bestseller or best-of list: 3–4 points
• Review or excerpt: 3 points
• Interview or feature: 2 points
• Mention: 1 point

Market reach

• International: 3 points
• National: 2 points
• Regional: 1 point

Optionally add a small momentum bonus if a title appears multiple times in the same period.

The goal isn’t precision — it’s comparability.

Note: The above is not meant to be prescriptive. Decide internally on the tiers and scoring that work for you.

The point of putting the info into a spreadsheet is that you can then integrate publicity mentions into analytics dashboards or create graphs or charts to highlight momentum. Turning unstructured email into a simple structured spreadsheet allows for analysis.

[Do you already do this? Have a template you’re willing to share? Or feedback on the benefits or drawbacks?]

Step 4: Use GA4 for context, not attribution

Once you’ve identified high-momentum titles, GA4 helps you ask better questions.

Focus on:

• Page trends for book and author pages (baseline lift, not spikes)
• New users and engagement over time
• Incoming traffic, look at the sources, during major publicity windows
• Excerpt downloads and outbound retail clicks, if tracked

Use annotations or reporting notes to mark major publicity moments, then review the 7–21 days after.

You’re looking for directional change, not proof.

Why this is worth doing

This approach helps marketing:

• Identify which books deserve extra marketing support
• Avoid spreading effort evenly across unequal signals
• Have clearer conversations with stakeholders about what publicity can and can’t do
• Use analytics to support judgment — not replace it

Most important, aim for something sustainable. No complex dashboards required. Just create enough structure to make better decisions.

The takeaway

Publicity doesn’t need to be justified by analytics to be valuable.

But when you give it light structure — tiers, scores, and context — analytics can finally help answer the right question:

Where is earned attention turning into real audience interest?

That’s a question worth measuring.